2025 Colts Training Camp: Injuries and a QB Dilemma
The Indianapolis Colts Face New Challenges in Preseason
The Indianapolis Colts are entering the second week of preseason play with more questions than answers. After a highly anticipated opener against the Baltimore Ravens, which brought national attention, the team needs to regain momentum to restore confidence among their fans.
One of the primary concerns for the Colts is their overall health. Before the weekend’s practices, the main worries revolved around Anthony Richardson’s pinkie injury and the loss of rookie cornerback Justin Walley, who tore his ACL during a joint practice with the Ravens. Unfortunately, those concerns have only grown as several players have faced nagging injuries this weekend.
Injuries Add to the Team's Struggles
During the practices, four players either left early or sat out entirely: WR Alec Pierce (groin), CB Kenny Moore II (knee), DE Kwity Paye (groin), and Nick Cross (hip flexor). Head coach Shane Steichen has not provided updates on the severity of these injuries, but the sheer number is concerning for the team heading into the regular season.
Even though LB Zaire Franklin made progress in his rehab by participating in team drills for the first time this summer, second-year LB Jaylon Carlies (knee, TBD) has yet to practice in August. With so much to work through before the season starts, this wave of injuries is the last thing the Colts needed.
The Quarterback Competition Heats Up
Regarding the quarterback competition, Daniel Jones appears to be gaining an edge over Anthony Richardson. While it's not a landslide, Richardson's recent injury has likely dampened expectations for the rest of training camp.
Richardson did suit up for the weekend practices, but his performance was inconsistent. During his first practice back, he struggled with efficiency, occasionally reverting to old habits with some off-target throws. However, his velocity and decisiveness remained consistent.
On Saturday, the practice focused heavily on the red zone, where Jones performed efficiently, completing 5 out of 6 passes. However, the context is important—Jones' session came from the 20-yard line, while Richardson's was from the 10-yard line. This difference highlights the need for Richardson to improve as a passer when closer to the goal line.
Despite the challenges, Richardson had moments of brilliance, including two touchdowns in 7-on-7 play and a rushing touchdown in 11-on-11. His first day back was not inspiring, but it was understandable given the injury to his throwing hand.
On Sunday, Richardson's performance was hit-or-miss. He started strong but then faltered, only to rebound later in the session. His inconsistency continues to raise questions about whether the injury is affecting his performance. Fans want to see stability from a player who has already been labeled as injury-prone.
Daniel Jones also had an inconsistent day, with off-target throws even in the short passing game. However, he found his rhythm toward the end of practice. One major concern remains: Jones' presence in the pocket. He allowed the pass rush to disrupt his timing, which is a critical issue for any quarterback.
A Tight Race Between Two QBs
The quarterback battle between Richardson and Jones is still very close, which is not what Colts fans want to hear. The goal of bringing in Jones was to allow Richardson to prove himself as the franchise's future. So far, Richardson hasn't separated himself from Jones, and with limited time left, the outlook is bleak.
Other Notable Developments
Second-year WR AD Mitchell has shown significant improvement since the pads came on. His strong performances in joint practices and this weekend suggest that he could become a key player if Pierce's injury causes him to miss time.
Rookie Tyler Warren has lived up to expectations, showing the same talent he displayed at Penn State. His preseason opener was impressive, and he continues to make an impact.
TE Will Mallory has also had a strong camp, transitioning into a potential big slot receiver rather than a traditional blocking tight end. He has been seen playing in bunch formations with the starters in 7-on-7 play.
With several defensive backs injured, rookie S Hunter Wohler has seen increased playing time, particularly in red zone situations.
WR Anthony Gould continues to show effort, but his recent drop issues are becoming a concern. RB Jonathan Taylor has been working on improving his hands, which could translate to better performance on gameday.
Finally, G Quenton Nelson praised Tyler Warren's work ethic, noting that he never has a bad day and is always striving to improve. This kind of dedication is exactly what the Colts need as they prepare for the regular season.